Oliver Roick

Data Storage and Indexing in DynamoDB

To power web-based applications, NoSQL databases can be a great and light-weight alternative to relational databases. The most significant difference to – say Postgres – is the way how data is stored, indexed and how it can be queried — all of this requires a different way of thinking about databases. I’ll explore how data storage, indexing, and querying works in DynamoDB, one of AWS’ NoSQL offerings.

The Use Case

Imagine you are building an app that organises content into several projects, and each of these projects belongs to a specific organisation. The data model is straightforward:

  1. An organisations table with the fields id and name .
  2. A table projectswith the fieldsid, name, organisation_id for a reference to the project organisation, owner (the username of the person who runs the project) and last_updated showing when the project was last updated.

The app supports several use cases and queries the data in several ways; for example:

In a relational database, we would put indexes on the fields we want to query, and the DBMS takes care of most of the heavy lifting for us. In DynamoDB you have to plan the queries upfront and prepare the indexes accordingly; and to write efficient queries and create useful indexes in DynamoDB requires an understanding it stores data.

Partitions and Partition Keys — How DynamoDB Stores Data

DynamoDB splits each table into various partitions. Depending on its size, a dataset it is stored as a series of subsets of the whole data set. Partitioning is handled by DynamoDB internally; the number of partitions in your table depends on the size of your dataset as well as the read and write capacity you have defined. On which of the partitions a new record ends up, is defined by the partition key. The partition key is part of the primary key, which can take two different forms:

A simple primary key consists of one field, such as the ID of a record. The simple primary key becomes the partition key. In this case, the value for the partition key must be unique. In our organisations table, we would use the id as the primary key, which automatically makes it the partition key for the table.

The other option is a composite primary key, a composition of a partition key and a sort key. The partition key defines in which partition the record is stored, and the sort key defines the order of records within the partition. In composite primary keys, many records can share the same partition key, but the sort key must be unique. In our example, we wouldn’t have a case to use a composite primary key. We can, however, tweak the projects table slightly. If we know up front, that we mostly query projects grouped by organisation, then the primary key could consist of the organisation_id and the name; organiziation_id is the partition key and the sort key is name.

Partition A
abc123Foo Projectjane2018-08-02
abc123Other Foo Projectjohn2018-03-02
Partition B
def456Bar Projectjane2018-03-12
def456Other Bar Projectsarah2017-12-06

The tables show the projects data set. Our data set is split into two partitions; partition A contains all records where the organisation_id is abc123 and partition B contains all record where the organisation_id is def456. Primary keys are indexed by default, which makes it easy to query an organisation using its organisation_id or to query all projects of an organisation. DynamoDB knows exactly in which partition a record can be found.

For other queries, DynamoDB would scan the complete table and filter out the relevant records. The reason lies in partitioning — to find all projects owned by a specific user, DynamoDB has to look across all partitions to find relevant records, which has implications on query performance. To mitigate that, we need to add indexes on those fields; called secondary indexes in DynamoDB.

Secondary Indexes

Indexing a field as a secondary index creates a copy of the base table into a new table and new partitions. The indexed field becomes the alternative key (i.e., the primary key in the index table) and is either an alternative partition key or alternative sort key. Creating a whole new table seems counterintuitive at first, but DynamoDB is optimised towards data-retrieval performance and not to simplify data management. To keep index tables small, not all fields from the base table are projected (i.e., copied) to the index table. Only the base table’s primary key and the alternative key are projected, any additional fields that you want to transfer over to the index table must be specifically named when setting up a secondary index.

DynamoDB knows two types of secondary indexes: Local and global secondary indexes.

Local secondary indexes

A local secondary index is used when you want to query a subset of records from a specific partition, but the records need to be ordered in a specific way to fulfil your query. In our example, retrieving all projects of an organisation that were updated in the last seven days would require a local secondary index on the last_updated field.

A local secondary index only changes the order inside a partition but not the partitioning itself. It uses the same partition key but a different sort key. Our projects table uses the organisation_id as the partition key and the name as the sort key. The corresponding local secondary index also uses the organisation_id as the partition key but the last_updated field as the sort key, allowing us to run queries against the last_udpated field without having to scan the whole data set. As depicted below, the partitioning is the same as the base table, but the order of records has changed according to the alternative sort key last_updated.

Partition A
abc1232018-03-02Other Foo Project
abc1232018-08-02Foo Project
Partition B
def4562017-12-06Other Bar Project
def4562018-03-12Bar Project

Global secondary indexes

Global secondary indexes, on the other hand, change the partition where DynamoDB stores the record. If you want to query all projects that are owned by a specific user, then you need a global secondary index on the project table’s owner field. owner becomes the partition key for the index table.

Partition A
janeabc123Foo Project
janedef456Bar Project
johnabc123Other Foo Project
Partition B
sarahdef456Other Bar Project

Using owner as the partition key, the partitioning is changed. Partition A now contains three records whereas partition B contains only one. Foo Project and Bar Project used to be on separate partitions, now they on the same. By querying the index, we can now quickly find the all projects for a specific owner.

Using Secondary Indexes to Query Data

Another important difference to relational databases is how we query data against indexed fields. In a relational database, you query the table, and the DBMS takes care of traversing the index and returning relevant records.

In DynamoDB, you query the index table directly. Remember not all fields are projected to the index, so the response can only contain the fields that are present in the index; if other fields need to be accessed, then another query to the base table is required. Knowing this is important when setting up an index.

When thinking about how data is stored, how indexes work, and how we query them in DynamoDB, it becomes clear that it is essential to think about how data is queried before designing a data model for DynamoDB. It’s up to the database admin to optimise the data model and its indexes towards reading performance, so it’s important to focus on a set of well-defined queries. If you don’t know how you will be querying your dataset in the long run, then you might be better off with a good old relational database.